file access dialogs (was Re: Save Dialogs)

[prev] [thread] [next] [lurker] [Date index for 2003/09/03]

From: Ann Barcomb
Subject: file access dialogs (was Re: Save Dialogs)
Date: 07:25 on 03 Sep 2003
Mark wrote:
> Which idiot came up with the idea of save dialogs?  I mean, I have a
> finder window open here (Explorer, I can see you from here, wipe that grin
> off your face - you do this too.)  It *is* the representation of that
> directory on the file system.  It should be to me one and the same thing.

What I dislike about file access dialogs are the ones that try to
'remember' where you saved the previous file, but don't distinguish
between 'open' and 'save'.  I've noted this on too many applications
to pick out a specific one to blame.

It's very annoying to plan to open several files in a row, do something
with them, and then save the results elsewhere.  If you open a file
in/some/very/nested/directory/structure, and save it in
a/different/long/location, the open should remain linked to the first
location, or at least some sort of shortcut should be available for
it, since I suppose there are people in the habit of opening the files
they just saved.  With me, I think that 90% of the time I'm manually
batch processing...usually saving a bunch of windows-format documents
in to a standard.

On odd file access dialogs, I've often wondered why gcombust (at least
the version I've got--0.1.47) selects a starting directory the way it does.
I think it's probably a bug since it doesn't make much sense as a
feature.  If you select files and directories, and then burn them on CD,
then return to select (to put on another CD), the working directory
the last directory in your previous input.  Not the last directory you
were selecting from, but the last directory from the list you selected
to burn.

Generated at 14:02 on 01 Jul 2004 by mariachi 0.52