Re: Syncing (was Re: DRM can bite my ass)

[prev] [thread] [next] [lurker] [Date index for 2006/12/05]

From: sabrina downard
Subject: Re: Syncing (was Re: DRM can bite my ass)
Date: 11:35 on 05 Dec 2006
> You miss the point.  The problem isn't that Apple uses DRM (or the
> particular variant they're using), it's the way they implemented
> syncing for the iPod shuffle.  It is explicitly a "nuke everything,
> write new stuff to the device" arrangement.  It is no great surprise
> under these circumstances that a poorly-restored music collection with
> out-of-date metadata is going to mean some loss of content.
>
> Which may or may not be hateful, but has nothing to do with DRM.

except that, IMO, the only justification for setting up the
destroy-by-default synchronization scheme -- which is, as other
posters note, contrary to general practice synching other gadgets --
is that they assume their users are *necessarily* infringing copyright
if they turn up with an MP3 on their iPod that isn't on the computer
that it's plugged into.  it may not be DRM in terms of CSS or AAC, but
it's "rights management."  i first enountered the data deletion (and
posted the original post in the "DRM can bite my ass" thread) when i
was just trying to recharge my shuffle, and plugged it into a handy
USB port one day, not expecting that it was going to do anything other
than mooch electrons.  that day i did get a warning, which i didn't
understand to mean "i am going to delete your data"; yesterday i
simply didn't get a warning at all.  improvement!

it's just all very hateful software behavior, though i'll grant that
it's almost certainly inspired by policy which is not entirely apple's
fault.  still, if they are going to give in to the man, they really
ought to give me a dialogue box which says plainly that my iPod is
going to be reformatted.

the really sad thing is that, all this notwithstanding, i'm still
pathetic enough to want one of the new tiny clippy shuffles.  there's
a word for people like me.

baaaaaaaa,
--s.
There's stuff above here

Generated at 23:01 on 05 Dec 2006 by mariachi 0.52